Integration Bee Questions
Recently MSS held its integration bee (think spelling bee, but integration questions) for 2023 and I was set aside the task of creating the questions. I always like this job (I did it last year as well), as coming up with good integrals is tricky. The aim is that the integrals can be done quickly if you know what you are doing (say in less than one minute), achieveable with only the basic integration techniques (substitution and integration by parts, and avoiding trig substitutions and hyperbolic functions if possible), but still can stump some contestants and wow the audience.
I have found that good later-stage questions will often involve some sort of trick that simplifies most of the question. This often means that I can incorporate many different parts of maths into the questions, even if integration is the underlying skill at play. The questions this year did this well, in my opinion. The difficulty ramped up a little too quickly (a lot of students hadn't touched an integral in years), but the top 8 contestants would usually spend two of the three minutes available, hitting the sweet spot between being solveable but still requiring thought. It's quite a sight to see a lecture hall of 30 silently focused on the scribbles of two students competing up on the whiteboard, and the cheers and banter that are shouted between rounds.
Without further ado, here are the questions I created, along with some brief comments about how to solve them. I also have the PDF we used if that's your preferred format.
Basic Questions
Question 0:
Answer:
This was the demo question we gave to show how to submit answers.
Question 1:
Answer:
Substitute .
Question 2:
Answer:
Question 3:
Answer:
Recall that . This took much longer to solve than expected; the nerves of solving problems infront of a crowd don't lend themselves well to integation.
Question 4:
Answer:
This one is much easier if you recall the difference of cubes formula, so:
Question 5:
Answer:
Substitute .
Question 6:
Answer:
I didn't make this one (it's the work of Ben Varley), but it worked well in the intial rounds. Got quite a few laughs and half-hearted sighs from the audience.
Question 8:
Answer:
Substitute .
Question 9:
Answer:
For this one, recall that . The bounds of integration are often forgotten when people are in the heat of the moment.
Question 10:
Answer:
A very common trick is to be aware odd and even functions. Here the first and third terms vanish to 0, making it a bit easier.
Question 11:
Answer:
Another one that Ben Varley wrote (it's quite beautiful). Using and we have: Substituting then leads to the solution.
Question 12:
Answer:
The product of (which is odd) and (which is even) is odd, so the symmetry of the bounds provides an easy solve.
Question 13:
Answer:
The first term is easier to solve once you remeber that (or if you remeber that ).
Intermediate Questions
These questions start to focus on combining techniques or less obvious uses of the techniques already used.
Question 14:
Answer:
The first one needing by parts. If this is known, it's not too tricky:
Question 15:
Answer:
The first double integral. Notice that the second and third terms vanish over the and domains respectively, and that we can split up the and components of the first term, so:
Question 16:
Answer:
This one might have been a bit too easy, as one of the contestants at the whiteboard knew the integral of (if you don't know it, consider doing by parts on ).
Question 17:
Answer:
Substituting provides the solution quite quickly.
Question 18:
Answer:
Things like this always get giggles and groans from the audience. Otherwise a simple integral given the substitution .
Question 19:
Answer:
This one isn't too bad if you convert to polar coordinates. Notice that so:
Question 20:
Answer:
This was a tricky one (that by parts eventually solves). It was well placed in the later rounds and almost didn't get solved in the 3 minutes given.
If we let be the original integral, we have: Therefore and so by rearranging for we get the desired result.
Question 21:
Answer:
This one isn't so bad once you realise that:
Question 22:
Answer:
This one is the first one that requires some more knowledge of trig to complete. First, note that . If you know the integral of (namely ), this then becomes easy.
Question 23:
Answer:
Start by substituting , getting the equal integral of Then using parts, this simplifies to which resolves down to
Question 24:
Answer:
After substituting , we get
This is the first question using partial fractions. I tried to avoid it as much as possible, as it's a bit of a time sink and not very interesting to watch. However, I made an exception in this case, as it's simple and quite late into the questions.
Question 25:
Answer:
Both terms can be simplified by the substitution , leaving the integral
Question 26:
Answer:
Noticing that , we can substitute , getting the integral Then by parts we get
Question 27:
Answer:
After substituting , this simplifies to
Question 28:
Answer:
This was one of my favourites to come up with. The secret (and this one very much relies upon a secret) is knowing the derivative of . As we have . This leads to the realisation that thus providing the answer.
Question 29:
Answer:
Notice that is odd whereas and are even, so the integrand is odd and so vanishes over a symmetric domain.
Difficult Questions
These questions are difficult not just for their integration techniques but also because they involve more out-of-the-box thinking. Depending on how you look at them, some of these may be easier. They do, however, provide a nice specticle for the end of the integration bee. It's quite remarkable to see someone solve a seemingly tricky integral just by thinking it over for a bit.
Question 30:
Answer:
This one follows well from the previous one. Starting by substituting , we get which we will call . Integration by parts will then reduce it down to: This means that our original integral is .
This ended up as the final integral this year. I think it was a good finale, with both contestants making some mistakes before one got the answer in the nick of time.
Question 31:
Answer:
This one needs a bit of care, by breaking it up into 3 parts. First, we have: From to , is positive, so this part of the integral is . From to , is negative, so we need to subtract . Finally, from to , is positive, so we will add on . Together, the total integral is .
Question 32:
Answer:
I think this is my favourite trick. I used it a lot last year. Notice that if we substitute then , we get the integral: Adding this to the original integral, we get As this is twice the original integral, we must have that it is .
Question 33:
Answer:
Substituting we get: The rest then follows from integration by parts.
Question 34:
Answer:
First, we will rearrange to get: As for our domain, we can replace with the geometric series . As the integral is sufficiently nice, we can swap the summation and integral signs, to get: Changing the bounds, we get that this is equal to By doing the inner integral via integration by parts, we find that it equals , so our original integral is equal to . This is the famous Basel sum, leading to such a nice answer.
This integral was inspired by a similar integral I saw solved online, I'm sure this is nothing new, but this technique really amazed me. I'll be trying in future to use it more.
Overall I think it had a good balance of difficulty. If you have any good problems or techniques, reach out, as I'm always interested to learn more.